Usernames are used for identification in two places in web services: To let people log in and to allow people recognizing each other. In this article I want to share some ideas on usernames.
Username vs Display name
When I look into my Stackoverflow profile, they have something called "display name":
I like this a lot. I communicates clearly that it is something seen by others.
The next question that popped to my mind was if we need usernames at all. Wouldn't it be simpler to just login with your password?
Two big problems with that idea:
- People might choose the same passwords
- Systems could allow multiple accounts and you might want to have autocompletion
This means we definitely need a username for logging in.
Display name restrictions
Is it a good idea to let people completely freely choose their username from any sequence of Unicode characters?
The problems I see with that:
- Design: People might choose names that break something. It's hard to have a nice design with a component that could grow arbitrarily.
- A minimum length might be desirable to make sure one can click on the name (at least one non-whitespace character)
- Identity theft: Think of the following usernames
- Script injection: By allowing
>an attacker could choose a username which loads HTML.
- Interactions: User interact. For example, in discussions they might
@martinto mention the user
martin. This means an
@character should be excluded.
- Markdown: Other caracters like
#=*~are also be a bad choice as they are part of Markdown.
$is a bad choice as it triggers MathJax / LaTeX.
- Natural seperators: Some characters are natural seperators in English,
German and French: Whitespace, Comma
., double point
- Offensive Language: Actually, the main problem I see here is when developers try to be smart and have a false positive - seeing something as offensive which is just the name of a person.
Where you might want freedom:
- Multiple charactersets for multi-country support (Kyrillic, Arabic, Chinese, ...)
What others do
|Twitter (Display Name)||1||50||Unicode||yes|
|Stack Overflow (Display Name)||3||30||letters, digits, spaces, apostrophes, hyphens||yes||must start with a letter or digit|